Tuesday, August 28, 2007

Lucia - The Confirmation

We will be interviewing Lucia Hill next Wednesday at 9am in the ICT!

Hurrah!

Now the research begins...

Tuesday, August 21, 2007

The Truth, The Whole Truth & Nothing But...

In the eyes of the public, journalists sit on the same rung of the honesty ladder as used-car salesmen.

The old line "Don't let the facts get in the way of a good story" has been fully and purposefully harnessed by some individuals and their publications (ie: NW, Who Weekly and the like).

I think a strong majority of journalists hold 'truth' and public duty as paramount to their position but often, the pressures placed on the modern journalist contribute to slipping standards.

As Sharon Tickle points out in her Tapsall & Varley chapter, (and as has been discussed in previous Theory of Journalism... blogs) the everyday reality of a journalist is "shaped by time pressures, market forces, law, work culture and practices, human frailty, and the journalist's experiences".

On the side of the public, Tickle expresses concern for the consumer in the technological age.

She asks: "In this digital age of textual and visual manipulation, can
the consumer ever be certain they are seeing the 'real thing'?"

In answer to Tickle's chapter, Nick, Dom & Ben presented a range of responses in their seminar presentations.

Nick retraced Tickle's path through the history of 'truth' from the theories of Plato and Aristotle to those of Foucault.

Nick and Ben both found a contradiction in the ability of one to be both an ideal journalist, and a post-modernistic think.

Ideally a journalist will be guided by the MEAA's Code of Ethics: to have "respect for truth and the public's right to information".

From Nick's presentation however, post-modernists pupport that a text has as many truths as it does readings.

Ben found these two identities to be mutually exclusive: to believe in one way would be contradictory of the other.

I agree.

It is dangerous territory to say that one is a journalist, reporting 'truthful' information to the public, when one does not at all expect the audience to interpret a report with the same purpose that it was written.

I think a middle-ground here could come from Journalist's awareness of the possibility that their reportage may be interpretted differently by individuals in different contexts.

To maintain honesty in reporting, effort should be put into minimising ambiguity.

Nick used footage of the Iraq war as an example of truthful reporting.

This was a great demonstration of how digital manipulation is playing an increasing role in modern news media.

Both film clips aimed to show the "real story" for US soldiers.

One clip was from an American TV show that gives troops video cameras to make video diaries of their experiences.

The show's producers then edit the footage down to fit in to a regular TV program.

The second clip was a rough clip of a shootout involving US soldiers from the top of an Iraqi building.

It was filmed by a soldier with a hand held camera and posted on Youtube.

Nick posed the question - what is the more 'truthful' representation of the war?

I think the lack of intervention involved in the production of the second clip results in something more representative of the truth.

It's sad to say, but media companies have such strong ties with such powerful people that it is hard to find 'real truth' that isn't tarnished by someone else's aims.

Finding "The Truth, The Whole Truth & Nothing But..." seems to be as tough as finding the definitive answer to the question what is a journalist.

Brickie, seamstress or lawyer?

Is journalism a trade, craft or profession?

The resounding response from the Seminar C presenters was that journalism can't be explicitly defined.

Melissa said that she believes "journalism resists categorisation (and that) it all depends on who you talk to". She quoted Oscar Wilde as saying he thought of journalism as "work", thus implying its categorisation as a trade.

The public have an insatiable curiosity to know everything. Except what is worth knowing. Journalism, conscious of this, and having tradesman-like habits, supplies their demands.
--Oscar Wilde
A trade refers to something that can be learned over a period of time, like through an apprenticeship or cadetship. Indeed these are ways that many senior journalists originally found their feet, but few modern-day newsroom rookies are allowed to walk through the door not clutching a degree.

Brad explored the idea of journalism as a profession. Does the requirement of education, primarily tertiary-based, and some element of special knowledge put journalists up there with doctors and lawyers? Journalists certainly don't enjoy the same legal privileges as their supposed counterparts.

Brad raised other similarities between journalists and other professional occupations. The office setting of the majority of an average journalist's day does not lend itself to commonality with a day in the life of a bricklayer. The provision of a "service" also gives a professional element to journalism. Is "news" a service or a tangible good? I think modern news is more like a service - journalists are providing snippets of information on radio, television and online.

To me, I see old-school newspaper journalism as a trade. In the golden days of the newspapers, journalists had the resources to get their hands dirty providing newspaper exclusives, a product of extensively researched investigative journalism.

News now has become something that you cop a quick hit of - instead of luxuriating with long newspaper articles and a cup of tea, we are more likely to see a news update on TV on the way out the door, a comment on the radio and a headline on an internet news site. I think this has given support to the news as service argument, thus also the argument for journalist as professional.

The concept of the citizen journalist however throws a big spanner in this notion. They are still providing a service, just not a professional one. I'll use the practice of medicine as an example:

Professional - GP, surgeon etc, fully qualified. You know you'll get proper, traditional care, in accordance with fairly standardised education & training methods. Same goes for a professional journalist. Ideally, they'll provide thoroughly researched, well-written balanced, articles.

Alternative - Aromatherapy consultant, etc. The practitioner has undergone some sort of training but is not necessarily required to meet any particular standards. This can be likened to some sorts of citizen journalists. They may provide accurate information and valued opinions, but have not received official training as a journalist or use alternative methods to distribute their comments.

Just Plain Dodgy - Malpractice suit anyone? This is for bloggers who can't spell and mainly write about what they fed their dog for breakfast. To me, that's not journalism, let alone anything resembling a trade, a craft or a profession.

As Melissa said, it all depends who you talk to.

Law & Order: SVU

Monday night's episode of Law & Order: SVU was based around the relationship between the press and the police - primarily a journalist and an info-leaking detective.

At first, the relationship with the journalist was strained - he spoiled one of their undercover surveillence efforts.

The detectives' case was ruined but the leaky detective, Olivia, didn't want the truth to be buried forever...

So, she secretly taped an interview with the suspect and passed it on to the journalist.

He wrote a damning exclusive with the leaked information.

When asked to reveal his sources, he made the decision to stay quiet.

He went to gaol.


Although it's a television show, this is a real risk for journalists.

The journalist had a sense of something bigger than himself - the public interest.

It was either going to be him or Olivia that would be sent to gaol and he saw it as his responsibility to tell the story and go down with the ship.

The lack of protection for journalists, particularly in Australia, is not comforting for those who acknowledge the "fourth estate" ideal of the media.

To encourage quality journalism and investigative journalism, protections should be considered for passionate journalists.

Lucia's in!

Lucia Hill has agreed to be interviewed.

I'm just waiting for her response on what days/times are suitable for her...

Tuesday, August 14, 2007

Senior Journalists

As part of our assessment, we are required to interview senior journalists in groups...

I was asked to contact local radio producer Lucia Hill.

I emailed her yesterday so fingers crossed...

Saturday, August 11, 2007

Seminar B: Reclaiming Journalism as Public Conversation

Renae's presentation raised some interesting points...

She said she thinks that Journalism should be reclaimed as public conversation. She said it has been removed from 'the people' for too long, existing as expert opinion. She was also critical of the role of PR, which was surprising considering that is her Major.

Renae said, and I agree, that news agendas are made by PR personnel and big businesses. She calls for a turn away from such a reliance on PR and a return to what is for 'the people'.

It is here though that the big debate of public journalism is raised:

What the public are interested in vs. What is in the public interest...

Sure, it might be in the public interest to know about child abuse in Aboriginal communities in the Northern Territory but when it comes to selling newspapers and getting ratings, some sordid affair/love child/scandal is always going to win out for the front page story.

It is here that infotainment gets a look in - get a celebrity angle in the Aboriginal story and it can have pride of place on the Sunday paper...

Infotainment can bridge the gap in the public interest debate.

Renae raised citizen journalism as a way the people can create public conversation.

According to Renae's presentation Public or Citizen Journalism can include:
  • Audience participation: SMS opinions & polls, 'send in your photos' segments/articles, online discussion forums & blogs.
  • Independent news & information sites: Gawker, Crikey etc. These are popular in Asia due to political constraints there.
  • Alternate information: anything that allows a community to communicate... includes school or neighbourhood newsletters, Reverb newspaper.

Renae also furthered the professional journalist vs. the citizen journalist debate.

  • "objectivity should be held over opinion" - i definitely agree with that... blogs are chock-full of opinions...
  • "sloppy technique" - as Renae said, this has more to do with the practitioner, rather than the movement.

Public Journalism and the citizen journalist movement though is an "important element of democracy".

Agreed.